Ellen Willis Responds  

I oppose the Bush administration’s drive to war on Iraq, though not without continuing internal argument. Should Saddam Hussein fail to comply with the Security Council’s resolution, I would have to rethink my position. In the event of a popular …



Editor’s Page  

Iraq is not Vietnam. Lyndon Johnson sacrificed a popular majority and promising social reforms to a futile war. George Bush – who won the presidency while losing the popular vote – and the leadership of Congress-which owes its legislative majorities …



American Culture Since 9/11  

These are heroes then-among the plain people-Heroes did you say? And why not? They give all they’ve got and ask no questions and take what comes and what more do you want? -Carl Sandburg, The People, Yes September 11, 2002, …



Ann Snitow Responds  

Regime change now? It would be wonderful if Saddam Hussein were gone, the miserable, old-style totalitarian thug. But do we want the new-style U.S. techno-thugs, smooth and increasingly precise, to take charge? Perhaps we’ll look back at communism and rogue …



The U.S. Role in the Four Wars  

I appreciate many of Michael Walzer’s thoughts on current Israeli-Palestinian conflicts (“The Four Wars of Israel/Palestine,” Fall 2002)—a topic on which he and I have often had trouble seeing eye-to-eye. The best part of his message is his insistence that …



Teaching the Lessons of 9/11  

As the first anniversary of September 11 approached, a controversy over the meaning of that fateful day and the place it will occupy in our national self-understanding irrupted into public view. The debate emerged not as battling manifestos by prominent …





Stanley Hoffmann Responds  

I would only support an American war against the current Iraqi regime if (1) the current regime blocks inspections and refuses to carry out its obligations to disarm and a renewed and reinforced policy of blockade, sanctions and deterrence has …



James B. Rule Responds  

I do not support an American attack against Iraq under current conditions. Such an attack would be justified only with a broad spectrum of international support, based on a convincing consensus of imminent and extraordinary danger. Both disarmament and regime …



The Importance of Being Lucid  

Jihad: The Trail of Political Islam by Gilles Kepel Harvard University Press, 2002 454 pp $29.95 Unholy War: Terror in the Name of Islam by John L. Esposito Oxford University Press, 2002 196 pp $25.00   Political Islam is all …







Kanan Makiya Responds  

I support a war on the grounds that the current regime of the Ba’ath Party in Iraq is a criminal state that has gone beyond the pale even as judged by the very low standards of the Middle East region, …



James Chapin, 1941-2002  

The name James Chapin may not be familiar to many Dissent readers. He didn’t write a great deal for the magazine. Until the last year or so of his life—when he turned out superb political analysis for an unlikely outlet, …