A Question of Zion: A Rejoinder to Jacqueline Rose

It is not surprising that Jacqueline Rose is unhappy with my review of her book (‘The Caricature of Zion,’ Democratiya, September 2006). Given the criticisms that I bring against the book, this is to be expected. Unfortunately, her response does nothing to dispel these criticisms; in fact, it manages to compound many of the problems that the review addresses.